I have the firm conviction that, since at least 1939, the Church of Rome has been led by saints in the persons of the Roman Pontiffs. Some may mock it, deride it, think it naive, or whatever they like; but it seems right and fitting to me that the Lord would ensure us such holy leadership in such an unprecedented time of cultural, social, philosophical, theological, and anthropological, upheaval. In other words, right when we need saints most.

If anyone wonders why I am quick to defend Pope Francis or his predecessor, it is precisely because of this conviction. I truly believe that we are inestimably blessed to live alongside two saints, two men who will and should be canonized one day (God willing, in my lifetime), and who have shown me the path to Jesus more clearly than I could have ever asked or deserved. I entirely missed out on the pontificate of St. John Paul II, because I was young and a Protestant; I will be damned if I miss the sanctity of the men put before me. If it were not enough that Christ promised that the ministry of St. Peter shall not fail, He has also made the Successors of Peter saints for just a time as this.

None of these popes have been without their mistakes. In this respect, they are not only no different from any other human being, but also from any other saint. Yet their lives show forth such a splendor of Christ’s love and truth that I cannot help but be convinced that they are holy men, sent to guide the Church through such trying times, in order that the Gospel of Jesus Christ will be shown with ever more radiance and clarity.

Each day, I pray to those popes who are already canonized (John XXIII, John Paul II); I pray for the canonization of those who are not (Pius XII, Paul VI, John Paul I), and for the hope of good reward for those still with us (Benedict and Francis). I pray that God may strengthen Pope Emeritus Benedict’s ministry of prayer for the Church and the world. I pray that God may keep and protect Pope Francis for many, many, many years and give success to his apostolic work. Each of these pontiffs is dear to my heart, shows me Christ, and gives me peace.

If this is not the case for others, I do not know what to say. If these men are not holy, I do not know what holiness is. But the Church has declared some of them saints, proposed others for our profound respect, and others are on the way to being canonized soon. I trust the Church more than I trust myself. Why would I trust myself more? I know myself too well by now, thanks be to God. I know nothing of God, nothing of holiness. I know only that the Church knows God and sanctity. When She tells me what either are, I lovingly obey. Such it is to be happily Catholic.

I am suspicious of any suspicion of the Church. I am wary of any wariness of the Pope or the college of bishops. And why should I not be? Would not the entertainment of such misgivings be only my old Protestant attitudes born anew to wreak havoc upon my faith and peace of mind? Is the attitude of mistrust towards the Successor of St. Peter and the successors of the apostles anything less than a satanic infiltration into the heart of faith? Is it anything other than an old error born anew; the fault in the human heart that defies God in favor of one’s own skewed loves? Has or has not God set up the Church to guide us, by the Holy Spirit, into all truth? That, for me, is the question to settle all things.

None of this means that my mind is absent or inattentive. Anyone who knows me knows that that is simply impossible for a personality such as mine; my mind is active to the point of its own detriment. But I cling to that maxim of St. Ignatius of Loyola, that saint I have not and still do not entirely like (yes, it is possible not to like the saints!): if the Church told me that black is white and white is black, I would believe it.

And why do I believe it? Not because I am some unthinking slob; not because I am some drooling ingrate. Because I have come to the conclusion, through exhaustive intellectual inquiry and spiritual journeying, that the Catholic Church is the one Church founded by the Lord Jesus Christ. There is no other Church founded by Christ. There is no other Faith handed down from the apostles. There is no other communion which can rightfully promise to Her members a happy life and eternal salvation.

Does this make me seem a peasant to some? So be it. The Church and Her Gospel, the Gospel of Jesus Christ the Son of God (may He have mercy on us), is foolishness to the world. Christianity in the West today has become sensible to the world, and as sensible as it is, I am tempted to say that that is so far as it is false. I am not afraid to say that I am Catholic, in happy communion with the Church of Rome, obedient as I can be to Her statutes and decrees, trustful as I can be to Her proclamations. With Chesterton, I do not want a religion that is right where I am right, but a religion that is right where I am wrong! And how wrong I am: daily, hourly! I am the most tide-drowned man who has ever lived!

Why am I a Catholic? Why do I love the Pope, the Successor of St. Peter? Why do I love the bishops, the successors of the Twelve Holy Apostles? Why do I submit to Holy Scripture, to Holy Tradition, to the Church founded by Jesus Christ?

I again echo Chesterton! There are ten thousand reasons all adding up to one reason: it is true.

And if it is not true, then damned be life! Sad and empty and pointless is life! Wretched and empty is life! Cursed be life, absurd and devoid of hope! Cursed be hope, nothing but a shell of deception!

But this is not so. This is simply not so. “Credo in unum Deum”– “I believe in one God”– that and what follows, that is my manifesto. It is the only manifesto I have to offer. It is not the only one that has changed the world but is the only one that has ever saved the world. By that manifesto I live and die, God help me. It is the only one that can change our hearts and heal our souls. It is the only one that saves us from the degrading slavery of being a product of our own age. The Gospel of Jesus Christ, in all its fullness and glory, given to us by the Catholic Church, is the only thing that gives anyone their true meaning, abundant peace, fullness of joy, boundless happiness, and silent contentment.

So I end my rant.


Venerable Pius XII, pray for me.

Saint John XXIII, pray for me.

Blessed Paul VI, pray for me.

Venerable John Paul I, pray for me.

St. John Paul II, pray for me.

And I know that Benedict and Francis pray for me, and I pray for them.

Axios and amen!

Liked this post? Take a second to support Where Peter Is on Patreon!

Joe Dantona is a convert living in eastern Ohio. He studied political science, history, and theology. He divides his free time between entertaining his wife and kids with dad jokes and getting distracted while reading good books.

Why I Trust the Pope

9 Responses

  1. Anne Lastman says:

    I have lived through the pontificates of Pius XII, St Pope John XXIII, Pope Paul VI, Pope john Paul I, St Pope John Paul II, pope Benedict XVI, and now Pope Francis.
    Have been in private audience with two of these Holy men, and as much as I believe in their goodness and holiness I reserve my most admiration for HH Pope Francis.
    For these turbulent moments in history one of the calibre of Pope Francis is needed
    We live in a time where the labourers have left their places if work and this shepherd has gone out looking for them all offering lanor to them and those he finds wounded he takes them to “the field hospital”.
    He is do close to his sheep he “smells like them”
    Indeed the Lord has looked upon our lowliness
    and sent a shepherd who would look for all the lost. HH Pope Francis, holder of the keys of the Kingdom

  2. SCOTT METZ says:


  3. Joe Crozier says:

    Well said Joe. I am happy to say I have been thrown off two so-called Catholic forums for having said as much, forums where Pope Francis has been called a malicious lying heretic and false Pope who is destroying The Faith. Keep The Faith just as you are.

  4. jong ricafort says:

    Great, I totally agree with you acknowledging the Saintly character of all the Popes you mentioned.
    But speaking of Pope Francis, this Pope I really admire in his ways and character…
    A very exceptional person, a rare gems with a profound wisdom and Mastery in the Art of War….
    All the Popes you mentioned had fought war with the church enemies but none with a magnitude like Pope Francis….
    I mean this is a Digital Age….Pope Francis is a recipient of daily character assassination from mainstream to social media and
    the worst not only from other faith but from the so called separated catholic groups or members.(Radical Trads,Sedes & Fake Trads)..
    but ofcourse the are good Traditionalist who are in Full Communion with Rome.

    Pope Benedict XVI for me is a Great Warrior Intercessor living up to it’s chosen name Holy Father St.Benedict. Why?
    Pope Benedict XVI had seen the strength and know the Church enemies during His Pontificate…and had chosen to fight them thru a Life of Prayer.
    We are so blessed in these end times we have a TWO GREAT POPES one interceding and the other battling the enemies upfront.

    If St.Padre Pio said the Rosary is the WEAPON, and St.John Paul II left us with a Weapon to Combat the Age of Darkness(Luminous Mystery)…our beloved Pope Francis is the WEAPON itself by living a LUMINOUS Life.
    The Luminous Mystery is our powerful weapon to lead us to victory as history had proven the power of the holy rosary to combat heresies and evil attacks.
    “In the End my Immaculate Heart will Triumph”

  5. Pat says:

    I would say that the church has had a long line of great and very holy popes going back to at least Pius ix and Gregory xvi. While this has been a great blessing for the church, it has given many the false impression that all popes are living saints who can do no wrong by virtue of being pope. So, while this line of exceptional popes has done much to prepare the church for the dark time that would come, it has also resulted in exaggerated concept of the papacy and even a bit of pope worship. People forget that there were quite a few unfortunate popes in the past who did and said a few unfortunate things, things which people of today would never think of attributing to the impulse of the Holy Spirit, or assigning to the temporal body of ordinary magisterium. It is the same exaggeration that causes people to fall into sede-vacantism,

  6. Chris dorf says:

    I have used the same argument myself that my belief is that God destined through his promise to safeguard the church and it has been especially needed in the twentieth and twenty-first centuries and God is faithful to his promise of providing Shepherd’s to keep the flag from being scattered when the world seem so clever in attempting to trip up the Body of Christ.

  7. Christopher Lake says:

    Joe, as a fellow Catholic convert (and a “revert” who spent many happy and committed years in evangelical Protestant communities before being convinced, through study and prayer, to return to the Catholic Church!), thanks for this piece of writing that is much more, and much better, than a mere “rant”– it’s in the great tradition of Chestertonian rhetoric which tells truths poetically! 🙂

    I was really encouraged to read this, and the encouragement, at least for me, is needed, in this time in which so many Catholics are only too willing to distrust and disparage Pope Francis. Now, I won’t lie; I’ve had my moments of struggle with him from time to time. In the end though, I have found that when I look deeper, beyond this or that headline, or this or that isolated quote, the true story of what he is doing becomes more clear to me.

    He is actually doing *many* things, many very good things. He is calling all of us to be Saints (and holding himself to the same high standard!). He is calling out the sinful human tendency to be self-righteous. He is reminding us, over and over, that while God wants His disciples to be holy, He is *merciful when we fall*, and we should run towards that mercy and not away from it in shame and self-castigation. He is going out to a secular world that increasingly does not know or understand basic Christian teachings and living out the loving, challenging work of evangelization. He is pointing every person who would seek and/or claim to follow Christ *towards Christ, radically*, as much as any Pope has who has ever held the office. That last point is one which I believe will be one of the “clinchers” in his eventually being declared a canonized Saint in the Church– along with, I pray, Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI. I respect and love both men deeply, for their respective witnesses to Christ, and for the difference they have made, and continue to make, in my life. Thanks be to God for them!

  8. Carol says:

    Thank you, Joe, for your honest perspective and heartfelt witness… I am weeping with you, brother. May God protect Papa Francisco and keep his mind in His peace.

Share via
Copy link